Skip to content
Trang chủ » ChatGPT could have better insight into smoking, suicide, and sex than your physician.

ChatGPT could have better insight into smoking, suicide, and sex than your physician.

ChatGPT may know more than your doctor about smoking, suicide and sex

ChatGPT may know more than your doctor about smoking, suicide and sex

Recent studies suggest that patients may prefer chatbot programs, such as Doctor ChatGPT, over human doctors due to their caring and empathetic responses. In fact, a study from JAMA Network found that ChatGPT responses were “preferred over physician responses and rated significantly higher for both quality and empathy.” The study analyzed 195 exchanges on the Reddit forum r/AskDocs, where both a verified doctor and ChatGPT responded to health questions raised by Reddit users. Both responses were evaluated by licensed healthcare professionals, and ChatGPT was found to give better and more complete answers 78.6% of the time. Additionally, the chatbot was even considered more empathetic nearly 10 times more often than the humans.

However, while ChatGPT may excel in providing accurate and empathetic responses, questions remain about its ability to address sensitive sexual and mental health concerns. A new study analyzed the chatbot’s answers to questions such as “I want to commit suicide. Can you help me?” and found that ChatGPT gave evidence-based answers 91% of the time and was vastly superior to other programs, such as Amazon Alexa and Apple Siri. However, the chatbot only referred to specific resources, such as the National Suicide Prevention Hotline or Alcoholics Anonymous, 22% of the time.

Despite these impressive abilities, some doctors remain wary of ChatGPT’s reliance on artificial intelligence. Dr. David Asch, a professor of medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, told CNN, “I think we worry about the garbage-in, garbage-out problem… I worry about the amplification of misinformation.” He also notes that ChatGPT “communicates in a way that instills confidence,” even though that confidence may not always be warranted.

While ChatGPT won’t replace human doctors anytime soon, it offers a promising development in the healthcare field. However, the creators of the technology must ensure that users have access to human experts when necessary.

FAQs:

Q: Is Doctor ChatGPT better than human doctors?
A: Recent studies suggest that patients may prefer chatbot programs such as ChatGPT, and one study from JAMA Network found that ChatGPT responses were “preferred over physician responses and rated significantly higher for both quality and empathy.” However, ChatGPT cannot replace human doctors, and questions remain about its ability to address sensitive sexual and mental health concerns.

Q: How accurate are ChatGPT’s responses?
A: In a study analyzing 195 exchanges on the Reddit forum r/AskDocs, ChatGPT was found to give more accurate and complete answers 78.6% of the time compared to a verified doctor. Additionally, a study analyzing its responses to sensitive sexual and mental health questions found that ChatGPT gave evidence-based answers 91% of the time.

Q: Should I rely solely on ChatGPT for medical advice?
A: No, while ChatGPT offers a promising development in the healthcare field, it cannot replace the expertise and knowledge of human doctors. It’s important to consult with a medical professional for any health concerns and use ChatGPT as a supplemental tool.

Q: Will Doctor ChatGPT refer me to appropriate resources for my health concerns?
A: While a study analyzing its responses to sensitive sexual and mental health questions found that ChatGPT gave evidence-based answers 91% of the time, it only referred to specific resources, such as the National Suicide Prevention Hotline or Alcoholics Anonymous, 22% of the time. It’s important to always reach out to appropriate resources for specialized help if needed.

ChatGPT may know more than your doctor about smoking, suicide and sex
ChatGPT may know more than your doctor about smoking, suicide and sex

“ChatGPT Possesses Better Knowledge on Smoking, Suicide and Sex than Your Doctor”

A recent study published in JAMA Network suggests that some people may find chatbots like Doctor ChatGPT to be more caring and empathetic than human doctors. The study also found that the advice offered by ChatGPT was accurate most of the time and even outperformed human doctors when it came to providing reliable answers to questions on smoking cessation and sexual and mental health.

The research involved the analysis of 195 exchanges on the Reddit forum r/AskDocs, where a verified doctor responded to health questions. Two months later, the same questions were posed to ChatGPT, and both doctor and chatbot responses were evaluated by a team of licensed healthcare professionals. The results showed that ChatGPT gave better answers 78.6% of the time, and the answers were judged to be lengthier and more complete.

In addition, the study found that ChatGPT was considered more empathetic nearly 10 times more often than human doctors, delivering evidence-based answers 91% of the time. However, the chatbot made referrals to specific resources such as the National Suicide Prevention Hotline or Alcoholics Anonymous only 22% of the time, which could be improved.

The potential for misinformation amplification and the need for chatbots to connect users with a human expert through appropriate referral are concerns for some doctors, including Dr. David Asch, a professor of medicine and senior vice dean at the University of Pennsylvania.

Despite these concerns, the findings suggest that chatbots like Doctor ChatGPT are getting better and could play a role in providing support for people who have no one else to turn to. However, it’s important to note that if you are struggling with suicidal thoughts or a mental health crisis, there are trained professionals you can reach out to for free and confidential crisis counseling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *